Intrinsic value calculation: a simple DCF method and its limits
How to calculate a stock's intrinsic value by discounting free cash flows: a five-step method, a worked example, a sensitivity table and the margin of safety to apply.
The most common intrinsic value calculation discounts future free cash flows: you project the cash flow per share over a few years, add a terminal value, then bring everything back to today with a discount rate. The result depends heavily on these assumptions, which is why you apply a margin of safety.
What is the intrinsic value of a stock?
It is your estimate of what a share is worth based on the cash the company will generate, regardless of today’s price. Two people with the same accounts can reach two different values, because each one picks their own assumptions.
Intrinsic value is therefore a range, not an exact figure. The share price is what the market asks today. The gap between the two is the margin of safety.
How do you calculate intrinsic value with a two-stage DCF?
The simplest DCF (discounted cash flow) takes five steps.
- The starting cash flow. Take free cash flow for the last fiscal year (operating cash flow minus capital expenditure, in the cash flow statement of the annual report) and divide it by the number of shares: free cash flow per share.
- The first stage. Choose an annual growth rate for this cash flow and a length, for example 10 years. Each year, the cash flow grows at that rate.
- The discount rate. This is the annual return you require. The cash flow of year n is worth cash flow / (1 + rate)ⁿ today: a dollar in ten years is worth less than a dollar today.
- The terminal value. After the first stage, the cash flow is assumed to grow forever at a low rate. Terminal value = last cash flow × (1 + long-term growth) / (discount rate − long-term growth), discounted like the last cash flow.
- The sum. Intrinsic value per share = sum of the discounted first-stage cash flows + discounted terminal value.
The simple DCF calculator does exactly this calculation, with no account. It also shows the share of the terminal value in the result and, if you enter the share price, the margin of safety. It rejects a starting cash flow that is negative or zero, and a discount rate that does not exceed long-term growth.
Which assumptions should you use?
None is right in principle. A few common benchmarks avoid the most frequent mistakes:
- First-stage growth. No more than the past growth of cash flow per share over five years, and often less: growth slows with size.
- Length of the first stage. 5 to 10 years. Beyond that, you extend a growth rate nobody can see that far ahead.
- Discount rate. The return you require for this level of risk. The more indebted or cyclical the company, the higher the rate should be.
- Long-term growth. No higher than the long-term growth of the economy, otherwise the company would end up larger than the whole economy. Values of 1 to 3% are common.
Example: Company A’s intrinsic value, step by step
Company A is fictitious. It publishes management software for medical practices. Its free cash flow per share was $3.00 in the last fiscal year, and its share price is $40.
Your assumptions: growth of 8% a year for 10 years, a discount rate of 9%, then long-term growth of 2%.
- First stage. The cash flow rises from $3.24 in year one to $6.48 in year ten. Discounted at 9%, these ten cash flows are worth $28.53 together today.
- Terminal value. 6.48 × 1.02 / (0.09 − 0.02) = $94.38 in ten years. Discounted over ten years, it is worth $39.87 today.
- Intrinsic value. 28.53 + 39.87, or $68.39 per share (to the cent, since the intermediate amounts are rounded).
- Share of the terminal value. 39.87 / 68.39 = 58%: more than half the value rests on the years after year ten.
- Margin of safety. (68.39 − 40) / 68.39 = 41.5%.
Why is the result so sensitive to the assumptions?
Change one assumption at a time, with the others as in the example, and watch the value move:
| Assumption changed | Estimated value | Margin at $40 |
|---|---|---|
| None (example) | $68.39 | 41.5% |
| Discount rate of 8% | $81.00 | 50.6% |
| Discount rate of 10% | $59.00 | 32.2% |
| Long-term growth of 1% | $63.07 | 36.6% |
| Long-term growth of 3% | $75.49 | 47.0% |
| First stage at 6% | $58.88 | 32.1% |
| First stage at 10% | $79.45 | 49.7% |
One more point on the discount rate takes 14% off the value. The reason: the terminal value divides by the gap between the discount rate and long-term growth. When that gap is small, a slight change in either one moves the result a lot.
Then combine the assumptions into two scenarios. Cautious version, with 5% growth, a 10% discount rate and 1.5% long-term growth: $45.93. Optimistic version, with 10% growth, an 8% discount rate and 2.5% long-term growth: $100.40. Your intrinsic value lies somewhere in between, not to the cent.
What margin of safety should you apply to intrinsic value?
The margin of safety is the gap between your value and the share price, divided by your value. It leaves room for estimation errors, and the margin of safety entry gives the usual thresholds by type of company.
The decisive question is which value you use. For Company A, at a share price of $40:
- with the central value of $68.39, the margin is 41.5%,
- with the cautious value of $45.93, it drops to 12.9%.
The Value preset strategy requires 30% for green and 15% for orange. The first value gives “Criterion met”, the second “Criterion not met”. Using the cautious value as your fair value is the most demanding choice, and the most consistent with the very idea of a margin.
How does ruly use your intrinsic value?
ruly does not calculate a DCF in the app: you enter your estimate per share in the “Fair value” field at the top of the sheet, using the method of your choice. The Value preset strategy derives the “Margin of safety (against the fair value entered)” criterion from it: you type the share price, the app calculates 1 − price / fair value and gives the verdict against the thresholds.
In your own strategy, a calculated value criterion computes the same gap between your fair value and the share price. The sheets are described in detail on the features page.
Frequently asked questions
Which discount rate should you choose?
The annual return you require to accept this company’s risk. Set it higher for an indebted, cyclical or young company. Always test one point more and one point less, as in the table above.
What if free cash flow is negative?
The simple DCF makes no sense: it would project a negative cash flow. For a company that invests heavily or loses money, the value rests on too many assumptions. Judge it on its cash, its debt and its growth instead.
Does the DCF take debt into account?
The calculator’s model starts from cash flow per share, from which interest on debt is partly deducted already. It does not add net cash or subtract net debt. For a heavily indebted or cash-rich company, adjust the value obtained by the net debt or net cash per share.
Are intrinsic value and price target the same thing?
No. Intrinsic value is your estimate of what the company is worth. A price target forecasts where the share price will be at a given date. The DCF says nothing about when the price might reach your value, or whether it will.
Start from the preset strategy “Value”: its criteria and thresholds are ready, all that is left is to enter your figures.
Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.