Skip to content
ruly

Investment decision journal: what to write and when to reread it

An investment decision journal records your thesis, your risks, your decision and the figures of the day. What to write, when to reread it and why each entry needs a date.

An investment decision journal is a dated record of each decision you make on a stock: your thesis, the risks that could invalidate it, the figures you used and the decision itself. Write the entry before you act, reread it after each earnings release, and compare what you expected with what happened. The date keeps your memory honest.

What should an investment journal entry contain?

Five items are enough. Each one answers a question you will ask yourself later.

ItemWhat to writeQuestion it answers later
DateThe day of the analysis and the report you usedWhat did I know at that time?
Figures of the dayThe value of each criterion, and the share price if a criterion uses itWhich figures did I decide on?
ThesisWhy this company, in three to five linesWas the reason right?
RisksWhat could invalidate the thesis, and the figure that would show itDid I see this coming?
Decision“I’m buying”, “I’m watching” or “I’m passing”What did I actually do?

Write the risks as checkable facts. “Competition” cannot be checked. “Operating margin falling below 12%” can.

When should you reread your investment journal?

After each earnings release, because that is when new figures can confirm or contradict the thesis. In the European Union, listed companies publish their annual financial report within four months of the end of their financial year, and their half-yearly report within three months of the end of the half-year. In the United States, the annual 10-K is due 60 to 90 days after the end of the fiscal year, and the quarterly 10-Q 40 to 45 days after the end of each of the first three quarters, depending on the size of the company.

Reread also before any new decision on the same stock, and once a year all your entries together, to spot the mistakes that come back.

How do you reread an entry after the results?

  1. Reread the thesis and the risks before opening the new report, so the new figures do not color your memory.
  2. Update each figure with the new accounts.
  3. Note which criteria changed verdict, and why.
  4. Check whether one of the risks you wrote down has materialized.
  5. Record the new decision, even if it has not changed: watching again is a decision too.
  6. Date the new entry, and leave the old one untouched.

Why does each entry need a date?

Once you know how a story ended, memory rewrites what you thought at the start. Psychologists call it hindsight bias: the outcome seems obvious afterwards, and the doubts you had disappear from your recollection. A dated entry, written before the outcome, is the only reliable record of what you knew.

The date also separates a good decision from a good outcome. A decision made for sound reasons can end badly, and a lucky one can end well. Only the dated reasons show which was which, and only that teaches you something for the next decision.

Worked example: Company A over three releases

Company A is fictitious. Its journal has three entries:

ReportFigures of the dayNoteDecision
Year 1 annual reportOperating margin 18%, net debt / EBITDA 1.2, P/E 24Thesis: steady margins. Risk: one customer makes 35% of revenue, check that the margin stays above 15%“I’m watching”: P/E above the 20 set as a maximum
Year 2 half-yearly reportMargin 17%, net debt / EBITDA 1.1, P/E 19The thesis is intact, the share price has fallen“I’m buying”
Year 2 annual reportMargin 13%, net debt / EBITDA 1.6, P/E 21The large customer cut its orders: the risk written in year 1 has materialized“I’m watching”, thesis rewritten

Without the first entry, the drop in margin could pass for a surprise. With it, you see that the risk was identified, measured, and that its threshold was crossed. The question for the next decision becomes concrete: how much weight should a single customer get?

How does ruly keep a decision journal?

In ruly, each sheet carries your thesis, your risks, a comment and your decision: “I’m buying as a priority”, “I’m buying”, “I’m watching”, “I’m waiting for a better price”, “I’m passing” or “Not decided yet”. The decision does not count in the score.

With the paid plan, frozen versions keep a dated snapshot of each analysis: the score, the verdict and the value of each criterion, with a copy of the strategy as it was that day. Freeze one after each release: the table of versions shows how each figure moved, and the score curve appears from three versions. Changing a threshold later does not change the versions already frozen.

Frequently asked questions

Notebook, spreadsheet or app: which one for an investment journal?

Any of them works if every entry is dated and never rewritten. A notebook is enough for a few decisions a year. A spreadsheet or an app helps when the figures matter and you want to compare them from one release to the next.

How long should an entry be?

A few lines. Three to five lines of thesis, two or three risks with the figure that would reveal them, and the decision. An entry that takes an hour to write will not be written after the third release.

Should I write an entry when I decide to do nothing?

Yes. Watching and passing are decisions, and they are the ones you forget most easily. A year later, the companies you passed on are often the best lesson.

What should I do when my thesis turns out to be wrong?

Write a new entry that says what changed and what you missed. Do not edit the old one: the gap between the two is precisely what the journal is for.

Start free

Build your strategy, score each stock against your own criteria and note your decision next to the figures.

Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.

Read next

Sources