Quality investing criteria: how to spot a high-quality company
Quality investing criteria (ROIC, margins, FCF conversion, debt, growth, share count), their usual thresholds, how to read them over five years, and the pitfalls to avoid.
A high-quality company earns a strong return on its capital, keeps high and stable margins, turns its earnings into cash, carries little debt, grows steadily and does not dilute its shareholders. Read these criteria over five to ten years: consistency matters more than the level of a single year, especially for a cyclical company.
Which criteria define a high-quality company?
Seven criteria come up in most quality checklists. The first six can be read in the annual report, the seventh calls for judgment. The benchmarks below are common thresholds, not rules.
- Return on invested capital (ROIC). Operating profit after tax divided by the capital tied up in the business. Benchmark: 15% or more on average. It is the central criterion, because it tells you how much the company earns on each dollar or euro it reinvests. See the ROIC entry.
- High and stable margins (gross margin, operating margin). A gross margin of at least 40% and an operating margin of at least 20%. A margin that barely moves from one year to the next shows a company that sets its prices instead of taking them.
- Turning earnings into cash (FCF conversion). Free cash flow divided by net income, averaged over five years. At 90% or more, almost all of the profit becomes available cash.
- Low debt (net debt to EBITDA). Net debt of 1.5 times EBITDA at most. The company can then get through a recession without depending on its lenders.
- Steady growth (revenue growth). Revenue up 8% or more per year on average over five years, with no sharp down year.
- Stable or falling share count. A rising share count dilutes every shareholder. Benchmark: no increase over five years.
- Competitive advantage. A patent, a network, high switching costs for customers, a brand. It cannot be measured directly, but high margins and a high ROIC over ten years are often its trace.
These benchmarks are those of the Long-term quality preset strategy. Its page explains each criterion, its “To monitor” and “Criterion not met” bands, and the price criterion it adds.
How do you read these criteria over several years?
A single year says almost nothing: a record year flatters every ratio, a restructuring year crushes them. Read each criterion over at least five years, ten for a cyclical company, following these steps.
- Write down every year, not only the average. An average of 16% can hide four years at 11% and one at 36%.
- Count the years above the threshold. Five years out of five above 15% tell you more than a 15% average.
- Measure the gap between the best and the worst year. An operating margin that moves between 18% and 22% is stable. Between 8% and 25%, it depends on the cycle or on one-off items.
- Follow the trend. A margin that loses one point a year for five years ends up below the threshold, even if each year taken alone clears it.
- Cross-check the criteria. Growth that speeds up while FCF conversion falls often signals swelling inventories or receivables.
Example: Company A over five years
Company A is fictitious. It makes measuring instruments for laboratories. Here are its figures, from the oldest year to the most recent.
| Indicator | Five years | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| ROIC | 17 → 18 → 16 → 19 → 18% | Above 15% every year |
| Gross margin | 52 → 53 → 51 → 54 → 53% | 3-point range |
| Operating margin | 21 → 22 → 19 → 23 → 22% | One year below 20% |
| FCF / net income | 95 → 88 → 102 → 91 → 97% | About 95% on average |
| Net debt / EBITDA | 0.8 → 0.6 → 2.1 → 1.6 → 1.2 | Peak in year 3 |
| Revenue (€m) | 600 → 640 → 680 → 740 → 790 | About 7% a year |
| Share count | 1% lower each year | Regular buybacks |
Quality shows first in consistency: ROIC stays above 15% all five years, gross margin moves by only 3 points, and FCF conversion runs at about 95%. Two lines need a closer look.
Debt first. At the end of year 3, Company A acquired a competitor, paid for partly with borrowed money. Net debt rises from 0.6 to 2.1 times EBITDA, then falls back to 1.2 within two years: the acquisition has been absorbed.
Then growth. The acquired business brings in €45m of revenue in the last year. Without it, revenue goes from €600m to €745m, which is organic growth of about 5.6% a year instead of 7%.
With the Long-term quality preset strategy, this 7% growth is “To monitor” (below the 8% threshold), and debt at 1.2 times EBITDA is a “Criterion met”. For your own reading, the figure to keep in mind is organic growth.
Which pitfalls distort quality criteria?
The top of the cycle
For a cyclical company (chemicals, steel, semiconductors, cars, shipping), ROIC and margins reach their record at the top of the cycle. Five good years can all fall within the same upswing. Read ten years, and compare the weakest year with the threshold, in addition to the average.
Acquisitions
An acquisition inflates reported growth without saying anything about organic growth, which the management report often gives separately. It also adds goodwill to the balance sheet, which lowers ROIC when you include it in invested capital. Always compare reported growth with growth on a like-for-like basis.
Buybacks paid for with debt
A falling share count meets the criterion. If the buybacks are funded by borrowing, net debt to EBITDA rises at the same time. Read these two criteria together.
Sectors where some criteria do not apply
- Banks and insurers. No gross margin, and debt is part of the business. They are assessed on return on equity and on solvency ratios.
- Real estate companies. High debt is the norm, and property acquisitions weigh on FCF. Operating cash flow and debt relative to asset value (loan to value) say more.
How does ruly apply these criteria to your sheets?
In ruly, each sheet starts from a strategy. The Long-term quality preset strategy contains the criteria on this page, read-only: duplicate it to change a threshold, add or remove a criterion. Competitive advantage is a yes or no criterion there, with a free note to describe it.
You enter the figures from the annual report yourself. Each criterion gets a verdict, “Criterion met”, “To monitor” or “Criterion not met”, and a complete sheet gets a score out of 100. For a bank, an insurer or a real estate company, check “Not applicable” on the criteria that do not fit: they are left out of the score. Details are on the features page.
Frequently asked questions
How many years of figures do you need to judge quality?
Five years at least. For a cyclical company, ten, so that at least one downturn is covered. With less than five years of history, after an IPO for example, a good stretch can pass for quality.
Is a high-quality company always expensive?
Not always, but its figures are public and its share price often reflects them. Judge quality and price separately. That is why the preset strategy adds a criterion comparing the current price to FCF with its five-year average.
Can a company be high quality without meeting every criterion?
Yes. A retailer can be sound with a 25% gross margin, because its model relies on volume. Adapt the thresholds to the sector in your own strategy rather than ruling out a whole sector.
How do you judge a competitive advantage?
Write in one sentence what stops a competitor from taking the customers: a patent, a network, a switching cost, a brand. Then check that the figures confirm it: a real advantage usually leaves high margins and a high ROIC over ten years.
Start from the preset strategy “Long-term quality”: its criteria and thresholds are ready, all that is left is to enter your figures.
Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.