How to pick dividend stocks: 7 criteria beyond the yield
How to pick dividend stocks: dividend track record and growth, payout ratio on earnings and on FCF, debt, a yield within a range, and two companies with the same yield compared.
To pick a dividend stock, check that the dividend can last and grow before you look at its level. Seven checks are enough: the payment track record, dividend growth, the payout ratio on earnings and on free cash flow, debt, earnings consistency, and a yield within a range rather than the highest one available.
Why is the yield not enough on its own?
The dividend yield divides the annual dividend by the share price. It rises when the dividend goes up, but also when the share price falls. An 8% yield can come from a generous company or from a market that doubts the next payment.
The yield tells you what the last dividend represents at today’s price. The other criteria tell you whether the company can afford to pay it again, and then to raise it.
Which criteria should you check to pick a dividend stock?
- Dividend track record. The number of consecutive years of increases, with no cut or suspension. A ten-year run usually covers at least one economic slowdown.
- Dividend growth. The average annual increase in the dividend per share over five years. Below the pace of inflation, your income loses real value every year.
- Payout ratio on earnings. The dividend divided by earnings per share. Up to 60%, the company keeps enough to invest and to absorb a bad year.
- FCF payout ratio. The dividend divided by free cash flow. A dividend is paid in cash: this ratio carries more weight than the previous one.
- Debt (net debt to EBITDA). Lenders come before shareholders. Up to 2.5 times EBITDA, debt leaves room. Above 3.5, the dividend may come after repayments.
- Earnings consistency. No loss over ten years. A dividend struggles to last when earnings turn negative.
- A yield within a range (dividend yield). High enough to matter for your income, not so high that it signals market doubt.
These benchmarks are those of the Growing dividend preset strategy, which adds an eighth criterion: the current yield against its five-year average. Its page details each threshold and its limits.
Why aim for a yield within a range rather than the highest one?
Beyond a certain level, a higher yield more often signals a risk than a bargain. The Growing dividend preset strategy assesses the yield as a range:
| Yield | Verdict | Reading |
|---|---|---|
| Below 1.5% | “Criterion not met” | Low income |
| 1.5% to 2.5% | “To monitor” | Modest income |
| 2.5% to 6% | “Criterion met” | Target zone |
| 6% to 8% | “To monitor” | Check the coverage |
| Above 8% | “Criterion not met” | Likely doubt about the payment |
These bounds are benchmarks. A fast-growing company can pay little and raise its dividend quickly. A real estate company distributes a large share of its earnings by nature. In a copy of the strategy, you move the range to match what you are looking for.
How do you calculate the payout ratio on earnings and on FCF?
Both ratios start from the annual dividend per share:
- Payout ratio on earnings = dividend per share / earnings per share.
- FCF payout ratio = dividend per share / free cash flow per share.
Earnings per share are in the income statement. Free cash flow is calculated from the cash flow statement: operating cash flow minus capital expenditure, divided by the number of shares.
The dividend yield and payout ratio calculator gives all three ratios from the dividend, the share price, earnings and FCF per share. It needs the dividend and at least one of the other three figures.
If the two payout ratios diverge, trust the second one. A payout ratio of 50% on earnings and 110% on FCF means that the earnings are not turning into cash.
Example: Company A and Company B, same 5% yield
Company A and Company B are fictitious. Both trade at €40 and pay a €2 dividend per share, a 5% yield. Everything else sets them apart.
| Criterion | Company A | Company B |
|---|---|---|
| Yield | 5% | 5% |
| Payout ratio on earnings | 57% | 91% |
| FCF payout ratio | 62.5% | 125% |
| Consecutive years of increases | 12 | 0 |
| Dividend growth, 5 years | 6% a year | 0% |
| Net debt / EBITDA | 1.8 | 3.9 |
| Positive earnings over 10 years | Yes | No |
| Average yield over 5 years | 4.6% | 3.2% |
The payout calculation: Company A earns €3.50 per share and generates €3.20 of FCF per share, so 2 / 3.50 = 57% and 2 / 3.20 = 62.5%. Company B earns €2.20 and generates €1.60, so 2 / 2.20 = 91% and 2 / 1.60 = 125%.
With the Growing dividend preset strategy, Company A gets seven “Criterion met” and one “To monitor”, as its FCF payout ratio is above 60%: a score of 94, “Criteria met”. Company B gets two “Criterion met” and six “Criterion not met”: a score of 25, “Criteria not met”.
The telling detail is in Company B. Its yield against its average is green: it went from 3.2% to 5% because the share price fell, and this criterion reads a low price compared with the past. The six others say why the price fell: a dividend larger than FCF, paid by an indebted company that has already reported a loss.
How does ruly apply these criteria to a dividend stock?
In ruly, the Growing dividend preset strategy contains the eight criteria on this page, read-only. You duplicate it to adapt it, for example for a real estate company: a higher payout ratio, or a criterion removed.
You enter the figures yourself, from the annual report or the source you already use. The yield against its average is calculated from the two yields you enter. Each criterion gets a verdict, a complete sheet gets a score out of 100, and your decision (“I’m buying as a priority”, “I’m buying”, “I’m watching”, “I’m waiting for a better price” or “I’m passing”) stays out of the score. Details are on the features page.
Frequently asked questions
What yield should you aim for with a dividend stock?
There is no ideal figure. The preset strategy targets 2.5% to 6%, a common benchmark. Above 6%, check the coverage by free cash flow before anything else.
Is a payout ratio above 100% always a bad sign?
A single year can have an explanation: earnings cut by a one-off charge, or a large one-time investment that reduces FCF. Several years in a row, the dividend is drawing on cash reserves or on debt.
How many years of dividend history should you look at?
Five years at least. Ten years show how the company treated its dividend during a slowdown: kept, cut or suspended.
What about dividend taxes?
They depend on your country of residence, the account that carries the shares, and sometimes the company’s country. They are not part of these criteria, which judge the company’s ability to pay. Check with the tax authority of your country.
How do you judge a bank or a real estate company that pays dividends?
A real estate company is better judged with a payout ratio measured on operating cash flow, a bank with its solvency ratios. In your sheet, check “Not applicable” on the criteria that do not fit: they are left out of the score.
Start from the preset strategy “Growing dividend”: its criteria and thresholds are ready, all that is left is to enter your figures.
Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.