Skip to content
ruly

Dividend trap: 9 warning signs to check on a high yield

Dividend trap: nine signs that a dividend cut may be coming (abnormal yield, payout above 100% of FCF, rising debt, falling earnings), as a checklist with a worked example.

A dividend trap is a stock whose yield looks high because its share price has fallen, often ahead of a dividend cut or suspension. The signs are in the accounts: a yield far above its own history, a dividend larger than free cash flow, debt rising to pay for it, and falling earnings.

What is a dividend trap?

The displayed yield is calculated on the last dividend paid. When the market expects a dividend cut, the share price falls ahead of it, and the displayed yield climbs. If the cut comes, that yield disappears, and the share price often falls further.

A dividend trap is different from a value trap. A value trap is a stock that looks cheap on its valuation ratios, such as a low P/E or a price below book value, while its business is deteriorating. A dividend trap is about a single question: can the company pay its current dividend? The same stock can be both.

This article is about spotting warning signs. For the criteria used to choose a dividend stock, read how to pick dividend stocks.

Which signs point to a dividend cut?

Go through each sign with the last two or three annual reports. A single sign often has an explanation. Several together show a trend.

  1. A yield far above its average. Compare the current yield with its five-year average. When it is 50% or more above that average (6% against 4%, for example), look for what the market expects.
  2. A yield inflated by a special dividend. Check that the dividend you use is the regular dividend. A special dividend, after the disposal of a business for example, inflates the yield for a single year.
  3. A payout ratio above 100% of earnings. The company pays out more than it earns over the year.
  4. A payout ratio above 100% of free cash flow, for several years. The dividend is larger than the cash the business generates once investment is paid for. One year can come from a large investment. Two or three in a row, much less often.
  5. A dividend funded by debt. In the cash flow statement, compare dividends paid with FCF, then look at financing cash flows. If new borrowing fills the gap, the dividend is paid on credit.
  6. Falling earnings. Two years of falling earnings per share, or a loss, push the payout ratio up even with a flat dividend.
  7. Rising debt. Net debt to EBITDA going up year after year, or large repayments due within two years, detailed in the notes to the accounts.
  8. Cut investment. Capital expenditure well below depreciation for several years improves today’s FCF at the expense of the future business.
  9. A frozen dividend or one paid in shares. After years of increases, a flat dividend, or a growing part paid in new shares, shows that management is protecting its cash.

The ratios for signs 3 and 4 can be worked out with the dividend yield and payout ratio calculator, from the dividend, earnings and FCF per share.

Example: Company A, 9% yield, run through the checklist

Company A is fictitious. It makes packaging. Its share price is €20 and its regular dividend is €1.80 per share, unchanged for three years after eight years of increases. The displayed yield is 9%, against a five-year average of 5.5%.

Over its last three years, earnings per share go from €2.40 to €2.10, then €1.60. FCF per share goes from €1.90 to €1.50, then €1.20. Net debt goes from 2.1 to 2.8, then 3.4 times EBITDA.

SignCompany APresent
1. Yield against its average9% against 5.5%Yes
2. Special dividendRegular dividendNo
3. Payout ratio on earnings112.5%Yes
4. FCF payout ratio120%, then 150%Yes
5. Dividend funded by debtBorrowing upYes
6. Falling earnings€2.40 → €1.60Yes
7. Rising debt2.1 → 3.4Yes
8. Cut investmentIn line with depreciationNo
9. Frozen dividendUnchanged for 3 yearsYes

The calculation: 1.80 / 1.60 = 112.5% of earnings, and 1.80 / 1.20 = 150% of FCF. The year before, 1.80 / 1.50 already gave 120%. The yield is 64% above its average: (9 − 5.5) / 5.5.

Seven signs out of nine. The 9% yield rests on a dividend that neither earnings nor FCF cover, and that debt has funded for two years. One figure says more than the displayed yield: the yield that FCF covers, €1.20 per share, or 6% at a €20 share price.

With the Growing dividend preset strategy, a 9% yield is a “Criterion not met” (above 8%), as are both payout ratios (above 80%). The yield against its average, on the other hand, is green: this criterion reads a yield above its average as a low price compared with the past. It is read together with the payout ratios, never alone.

How does ruly help you track these signs?

In ruly, you enter the figures, and your strategy judges them. The Growing dividend preset strategy already covers several signs: the maximum yield, both payout ratios, net debt to EBITDA and positive earnings every year for ten years.

Duplicate it to add the others, for example a yes or no criterion on whether debt funds the dividend. With the paid plan, frozen versions keep the value of each criterion at each review: you see the payout ratio rise or the debt climb from one version to the next.

Frequently asked questions

Is a high yield always a trap?

No. Some companies distribute a large share of their earnings by nature, such as real estate companies. A high yield becomes suspicious when it moves well away from its own history and FCF no longer covers it.

What is the difference between a dividend trap and a value trap?

A value trap is about valuation: a low P/E that stays low because earnings fall. A dividend trap is about the payment: a high yield that disappears when the dividend is cut. Both often share the same cause, a deteriorating business.

How many signs make a trap?

There is no magic number. A single sign often has an explanation. An FCF payout ratio above 100% for several years, together with rising debt, is the most telling combination, because it shows a dividend paid on credit.

What should I do if a stock I own shows several signs?

Reread your thesis and the invalidation thresholds you set. If one of them is crossed, you already know what you had planned to do. The decision remains yours.

Choose this strategy

Start from the preset strategy “Growing dividend”: its criteria and thresholds are ready, all that is left is to enter your figures.

Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.

Read next