Exit criteria for stocks: decide in advance when to part with a stock
Exit criteria for stocks: the four families of rules to write before you invest, what is not enough on its own to exit, trimming versus exiting, and a fictitious worked example.
An exit criterion is a rule you write before investing that says under which condition you part with a stock. Four families cover most cases: the thesis invalidated by a crossed threshold, a valuation above your own maximum, a position grown too large, and a better alternative by your own criteria. A falling share price is not one of them.
Why write your exit criteria before you invest?
Because before you invest, you read the figures with nothing at stake. Once you own the stock, every piece of news gets read through that position: a weak release becomes “temporary”, a strong one becomes “the proof”. A rule written in a calm moment does not depend on how you feel the day it applies.
Writing the exit also forces you to sharpen the entry. If you cannot say what would make you leave, you do not yet know why you are getting in. Exit criteria extend the risks section of an investment thesis: each risk already has a figure and a threshold, and what remains is to write the move that follows.
What are the four families of exit criteria?
| Family | Example of a written rule |
|---|---|
| Thesis invalidated | Operating margin below 14% two half-years in a row |
| Valuation above your maximum | P/E above 30, or share price 30% above your fair value |
| Position too large | Position above 10% of the portfolio |
| Better alternative | Another sheet in your strategy with a score 15 points higher and a valuation below your maximum |
The thresholds in this table are examples. These are your rules, and setting them is up to you.
The thesis is invalidated
This is the most important family. Your thesis rests on three or four figures, and each one has an invalidation threshold. When one is crossed, the reason you own the stock no longer stands.
Write the rule over a period rather than on a single figure: “two half-years in a row” keeps you from exiting on a one-off item. Check the cause too: a margin crushed by a one-time impairment does not say the same thing as a margin eroded by competition.
The valuation exceeds your maximum
The company is doing well, but the price already reflects far more than you estimate. Set a maximum in figures: a P/E, a price to free cash flow, or a gap to your own fair value. Put this exit maximum above your entry maximum, so the position does not turn over at the slightest move.
The position has grown too large
A position that has done well ends up weighing heavily in your portfolio. The risk then changes in kind: a single piece of bad news hits a large share of your savings. Write a maximum weight and a target weight, for example 10% and 7%.
A better alternative exists
Your money is limited. If another company meets your own criteria better, at a valuation you accept, the question arises. Write a minimum gap, in score points or in yield, so you do not switch positions for a marginal difference.
What is not enough on its own to exit?
These signals can trigger a reread. None is enough by itself.
| Signal | Why it is not enough by itself |
|---|---|
| The share price fell 30% | It changes the valuation, not the company’s figures |
| A 50% gain is reached | Your entry price says nothing about what the company is worth today |
| The share price has been flat for two years | If the figures have grown, the stock is cheaper than at entry |
| A rumor or an article | The figure that would confirm it comes with the next report |
Faced with one of these signals, go through your exit criteria. If none is crossed, your rule has already answered.
Should you trim or exit completely?
Write the move at the same time as the rule. One way to pair them:
- Thesis invalidated: full exit, since the reason to be a shareholder is gone.
- Valuation above your maximum: trim part of the position, and keep the rest as long as the thesis stands.
- Position too large: trim back to the target weight, without touching the thesis.
- Better alternative: trim to fund the other position, or exit if the gap is confirmed over two releases.
Add a delay: “I reread within the week, and I decide within the month”. It keeps you from deciding on earnings day, under the sway of the share price.
Worked example: Company A’s exit criteria
Company A is fictitious. It makes industrial pumps. The day you note “I’m buying”, you write four rules in its risks:
- Thesis invalidated: operating margin below 14% two half-years in a row, or net debt / EBITDA above 2.5. Move: full exit.
- Valuation: P/E above 30. Move: trim by half.
- Weight: more than 10% of the portfolio. Move: trim back to 7%.
- Alternative: another sheet in your strategy with a score 15 points higher and a P/E below 20. Move: compare the two theses.
Here is what happens next:
- Year 2. The share price rises, and the position reaches 11% of the portfolio. The weight rule applies: you trim back to 7%. The thesis is not in question.
- Year 3, half-yearly report. The operating margin falls to 13.8%. One half-year only: the rule is not crossed. You reread the thesis and note “I’m watching”, with the threshold to check at the annual report.
- Year 3, annual report. The second-half margin is 13.1%, with no one-off item. The rule is crossed. The share price has fallen 20% in the meantime, and the urge to wait for a rebound is strong.
- Decision. You apply the rule written two years earlier: “I’m passing”, full exit within the month, and one line that says why.
Without a written rule, step 3 would have been decided by the share price. With it, the question asked is the one you had chosen: does the margin stand up?
How does ruly help you track your exit criteria?
In ruly, each sheet carries your thesis, your risks (“What could invalidate the thesis”), a comment and your decision: “I’m buying as a priority”, “I’m buying”, “I’m watching”, “I’m waiting for a better price”, “I’m passing” or “Not decided yet”. The risks are the natural place to write your exit criteria and the planned move. The decision does not count in the score.
The thresholds of your strategy give each figure a verdict: “Criterion met”, “To monitor” or “Criterion not met”. A criterion that turns red on a sheet with the “In portfolio” status points you to the rule to reread. The sheet does not record the amount invested: track the weight of a position in your portfolio separately.
Frequently asked questions
Is an exit criterion the same as a stop order?
No. A stop order triggers on the share price alone, without looking at the company. An exit criterion rests first on the company’s figures or on your own valuation, and you decide the move, within the delay you set yourself.
What if a criterion is crossed but I still believe in the company?
Write a new dated thesis that explains why the threshold no longer matters, with a new figure and a new threshold. If you do this every time a rule bothers you, the rule itself needs revising, between two analyses and not on the day it applies.
How many exit criteria should I write?
Three to five per stock are enough: one or two invalidation thresholds for the thesis, a valuation maximum, a maximum weight. The alternative family can stay common to all your positions.
Do I need exit criteria for a stock I am watching?
For a stock on watch, the equivalent is the condition that would make you remove it from your stock watchlist: the figure that would prove the thesis wrong before you have even invested.
Build your strategy, score each stock against your own criteria and note your decision next to the figures.
Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.