Skip to content
ruly

Stick to your investment rules: criteria first, share price last

How to stick to your investment rules: write your criteria and thresholds before looking at the share price, note each decision with its reasons, and reread it after the results.

To stick to your investment rules, write them down before you look at a stock: criteria, thresholds, and what would make you pass. Fill them in with figures from the annual report, check the share price last, and note your decision with its reasons. Reread it after the next results. Change a rule between two analyses, never during one.

Why is it hard to follow your own investment rules?

Because the decision rarely happens in a calm moment. A share price that has just fallen, a company everyone talks about, a story you like: each one pushes you to bend a threshold “just this once”. Unwritten rules bend without anyone noticing, including yourself.

Trading often also has a measurable cost. In a study of 66,465 US households followed from 1991 to 1996, those that traded the most earned an annual return of 11.4%, against 17.9% for the market and 16.4% for the average household. Written rules promise no result, but they slow down the decisions made in the heat of the moment.

How do you write rules you can actually follow?

  1. Turn each rule into a criterion with a figure: “net debt / EBITDA at most 2”, not “not too much debt”.
  2. Set every threshold before analyzing any company, and note why you chose it.
  3. Add an orange zone for borderline cases, so that a figure just past the line does not tempt you to move the line.
  4. Write down what would make you pass on a company, not only what would make you invest.
  5. Keep 6 to 12 criteria. Beyond that, nobody fills them all in for long.

The preset strategies give common thresholds for four investing styles, to duplicate and adapt rather than to follow as they are.

Why look at the share price last?

Because the price anchors everything that follows. Once you know a stock has fallen 30%, every figure reads as an opportunity, and once you know it has doubled, every figure reads as a risk. Fill in the criteria about the business first: profitability, debt, cash. Then estimate what the company is worth with your own method, and only then compare that estimate with the share price. The margin of safety calculator does that last comparison without an account.

What should you note at the moment you decide?

The date, the figures of the day, your thesis in a few lines, the risks that would invalidate it, and the decision itself: “I’m buying”, “I’m watching” or “I’m passing”. Write it before acting. A decision explained after the fact is a justification, and it teaches you nothing.

When is it fine to change a rule?

Between two analyses, after reviewing several companies. Never to let a stock you like through.

Good reason to change a ruleBad reason to change a rule
The criterion does not apply to a sector you now followA company you like misses it by a little
After a year of use, the criterion has never changed a decisionThe share price rose while you were waiting
You found an error in the formula or in the figure it readsThe news or a forum says the opposite

When you change a rule, date the change and keep the old analyses as they were: they record what you decided with the rule of the time.

Worked example: Company A

Company A is fictitious. Since the start of the year, your strategy has said: net debt / EBITDA at most 2, orange up to 2.5. After an acquisition, Company A shows 2.8. Its share price has just fallen 25%, and the acquisition story is appealing. The temptation is to raise the threshold to 3.

You keep the rule. The criterion is not met, and the score of the sheet goes from 85 to 75. You note “I’m watching”, with a written risk: “debt after the acquisition, check at the half-year that net debt / EBITDA falls back below 2.5”. Six months later, the ratio is 2.3: the criterion moves to orange, and you decide again with the figures in hand, not with the memory of a share price.

How does ruly help you stick to your rules?

In ruly, your rules are the criteria and thresholds of a strategy, written once, before any analysis. Each sheet applies the same thresholds to every company: the verdict of a criterion depends only on the figure you enter and on your threshold. Your decision, “I’m buying as a priority”, “I’m buying”, “I’m watching”, “I’m waiting for a better price” or “I’m passing”, is noted next to the figures, with your thesis and your risks.

With the paid plan, frozen versions keep a copy of the strategy as it was on the day of the analysis: changing a rule later does not rewrite the analyses already made.

Frequently asked questions

What if an excellent company misses one criterion?

Let the verdict stand, and read it. One criterion not met does not exclude a company: the score and the other verdicts still count, and the decision remains yours. Write down why you decide despite the miss, and check that reason at the next results.

Should my rules differ by sector?

For banks, insurers and real estate companies, yes: margins and debt ratios do not read the same way. Build a separate set of rules for them rather than exceptions in the main one.

Can I break a rule once?

You can, but write it down with the reason, on the day. At the next results, check whether the reason proved right. If exceptions keep coming back, the rule itself needs to change, between two analyses.

How often should I review my rules?

Once a year is enough for most investors, with all your analyses of the year side by side. Look for the criteria that never changed a decision and the ones you were tempted to bend.

Start free

Build your strategy, score each stock against your own criteria and note your decision next to the figures.

Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.

Read next

Sources