Skip to content
ruly

Stock investment checklist: how to build, weight and apply it

How to build a stock investment checklist: choose 6 to 12 criteria, set a threshold for each one, weight those that matter most and apply the same list to every stock.

A stock investment checklist is a short list of written criteria, each with a threshold, that you apply to every company before you decide. Build it from three or four questions about profitability, debt, cash and valuation. Keep 6 to 12 criteria, give more weight to the ones that matter most, and score every stock the same way.

Why use a checklist to analyze stocks?

A checklist makes you look at the same points for every company, in the same order. Without one, attention goes to whatever stands out in the news or in the share price, and a weak point slips by because the story is appealing.

Written criteria also leave a trace. A year later, you can see what you checked, what you missed and which threshold you set at the time.

Which criteria belong on a stock checklist?

Start from questions, not from indicators. Each question becomes one or two criteria. Cover several angles rather than several variants of the same ratio.

QuestionExample criteriaWhere to read the figures
Is the business profitable?ROIC, operating marginIncome statement, balance sheet
Is the debt reasonable?Net debt / EBITDA, current ratioBalance sheet, notes
Does profit turn into cash?FCF conversionCash flow statement
Is the price reasonable?P/E, FCF yield, margin of safetyIncome statement, share price
What do the figures miss?Competitive advantage, founders among shareholdersAnnual report, your own notes

The glossary of indicators gives the formula of each one, where to find it in an annual report and the usual pitfalls.

How many criteria should a checklist have?

Between 6 and 12 in most cases. Below 6, a single figure decides everything. Beyond 12, filling in the checklist takes a long time, each criterion weighs less in the score, and lines start getting skipped. A short checklist you fill in completely is worth more than a long one left half empty.

How do you set a threshold for each criterion?

A threshold turns a figure into a verdict. Three forms cover most cases:

  1. Minimum, when higher is better: an operating margin of at least 15%.
  2. Maximum, when lower is better: net debt / EBITDA of at most 2.
  3. Range, when both extremes are a warning: a dividend yield between 2% and 6%, since a very high yield often signals a dividend at risk.

A second, looser threshold opens an orange zone, “to monitor”, between a criterion met and a criterion not met. It keeps a borderline figure from flipping the verdict on its own.

If you do not know where to start, the preset strategies give common benchmarks for four styles: long-term quality, growing dividend, value and reasonable growth. They are starting points to duplicate and adjust, not rules, and they predict no result.

The four preset strategies also come as a free spreadsheet, with no sign-up: download the stock checklist template for Excel, which also opens in LibreOffice and Google Sheets.

How do you weight the criteria?

Give every criterion a weight of 1 at first. After a few companies, raise to 2 or 3 the ones that really drive your decision, such as ROIC for a quality investor or the payout ratio for a dividend investor. A weight of 5 on one criterion lets it decide almost alone: keep that for a deliberate choice.

A simple score then sums up the checklist: 2 points for a criterion met, 1 for a criterion to monitor, 0 for a criterion not met, each multiplied by its weight, divided by the total possible.

How do you apply the checklist to each stock?

  1. Take the latest annual report, and the two or three before it for criteria measured over several years.
  2. Enter each figure, criterion by criterion, before looking at the share price chart.
  3. Read the verdict of each criterion, then the score.
  4. Write your thesis and the main risks in a few lines, then your decision.
  5. Repeat after each annual or half-yearly report, with the same checklist.

Worked example: Company A

Company A is fictitious. Its checklist has six criteria, with these thresholds and weights:

CriterionRuleCompany AVerdict, points
ROICAt least 15%, orange from 10%, weight 317%Criterion met, 6 of 6
Operating marginAt least 15%, orange from 8%, weight 212%To monitor, 2 of 4
Revenue growth, 5 yearsAt least 5% a year, orange from 2%, weight 16%Criterion met, 2 of 2
Net debt / EBITDAAt most 2, orange up to 3, weight 21.4Criterion met, 4 of 4
FCF conversionAt least 80%, orange from 60%, weight 155%Criterion not met, 0 of 2
P/EAt most 20, orange up to 25, weight 222To monitor, 2 of 4

Company A collects 16 points out of 22 possible, a score of 73 out of 100: “Criteria partly met”. The score shows that Company A meets most of the chosen criteria, and it points to two things to dig into: a margin below target, and profit that turns poorly into cash. What to do with the stock remains your decision.

How does ruly apply your checklist?

In ruly, your checklist is called a strategy: a list of criteria, each with its thresholds and a weight from 1 to 5. Start from one of the four preset strategies and duplicate it to adapt it, or write your own. For each stock, a sheet follows your strategy: each figure you enter turns green, orange or red, a criterion that does not concern the company can be checked “Not applicable” and leaves the score, and the complete sheet gets a score out of 100.

Steps 2 to 5 above then fit in a single sheet, which you pick up again after each report.

Frequently asked questions

Should every criterion carry the same weight?

At first, yes. Equal weights show which criteria actually change your mind. Once you know, raise the weight of two or three of them and write down why.

Does the same checklist work for banks, insurers and real estate companies?

Not as it is. Margins, net debt / EBITDA and free cash flow make little sense for a bank or an insurer, and depreciation weighs on the earnings of real estate companies. Build a separate checklist for them, or mark the criteria concerned as not applicable.

Is a high score a reason to invest?

A high score says that the company meets the criteria you chose, with the figures you entered. It is neither advice nor a forecast. Two companies at 75 can have very different profiles: read the verdict of each criterion, and compare companies scored with the same checklist.

When should I change my checklist?

After using it on several companies, and never in the middle of an analysis to fit a stock you like. Note why you set each threshold: a year later, you will know whether it came from a conviction or from a provisional setting.

Start free

Build your strategy, score each stock against your own criteria and note your decision next to the figures.

Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.

Read next