Skip to content
ruly

How to analyze a stock: a 5-step method with a worked example

How to analyze a stock in 5 steps: understand the business, read the accounts, apply your criteria, judge the price, then write your thesis, risks and decision. Worked example.

To analyze a stock, follow five steps in order: understand the company’s business, read its accounts over three to five years, apply your written criteria, judge the price, then write your thesis, your risks and your decision. The price comes fourth, so the share price does not color how you read the figures.

What are the 5 steps to analyze a stock?

  1. Understand the business. What the company offers, to whom, and how it makes money. You come away with two sentences.
  2. Read the accounts. Income statement, balance sheet and cash flow statement, over three to five fiscal years. You come away with a dozen figures.
  3. Apply your criteria. Each figure against your threshold. You come away with a verdict per criterion and a score.
  4. Judge the price. Multiples, yields, or your own estimate of value. You come away with a maximum price or a margin of safety.
  5. Write thesis, risks and decision. You come away with five lines of thesis, an invalidation threshold per risk and a dated decision.

Step 1: what does the company do and how does it make money?

Start with the management report at the front of the annual report (in a 10-K, the business description and the MD&A), then the segment information in the notes. It breaks down revenue and profit by business line and by region.

Answer four questions: what does it offer, to whom, how does it get paid (one-off payment, subscription, multi-year contract), and who are its competitors? If you cannot explain it in two sentences, stop there: you will not be able to judge its figures.

The guide to analyzing a stock with the annual report shows where to find each part of the document.

Step 2: which figures should you read in the accounts?

Read at least three fiscal years, to see a trend rather than an isolated year. Five figures cover the essentials: revenue growth, operating margin, ROIC, net debt / EBITDA and FCF conversion.

Copy the raw figures before you calculate anything, and note the definition you used (reported or adjusted earnings, basic or diluted shares). You will be able to redo every calculation later. The financial ratios for stock analysis give the formula and the reading of each one.

Step 3: how do you apply your criteria?

Compare each figure with the threshold you set before you looked at the company. Each criterion gets a verdict: met, to monitor or not met. Mark as not applicable whatever makes no sense in that sector, such as a gross margin for a bank.

Criteria written in advance keep you from adjusting the thresholds to a company you like. A stock analysis template sorted by family (profitability, balance sheet, cash flow, growth, valuation, qualitative) helps you forget none.

Step 4: how do you judge whether the price is reasonable?

A good company can cost too much. Look at the price from three angles:

  1. A multiple against your maximum: P/E, enterprise value / EBIT.
  2. A yield against your minimum: FCF yield.
  3. Today’s multiple against its own five-year average.

You can also estimate a value per share yourself, then demand a gap with the share price: that is the margin of safety. The guide to intrinsic value calculation walks through the approaches and their assumptions.

Step 5: how do you write your thesis, risks and decision?

The thesis keeps the three or four figures that drive your decision. Each risk gets the figure that would reveal it and an invalidation threshold. The decision fits in a few words, “I’m buying”, “I’m watching” or “I’m passing”, with the date of the next reread.

The investment thesis template gives the six sections to fill in, with a complete example.

What comes after the decision?

The analysis goes on with each earnings release: you compare the new figures with your thresholds again. The method to review stocks after earnings says what to look at first.

Keep a dated record of each decision and each reread in an investment decision journal. A year later, you will know what you had seen, and what you had missed.

Worked example: Company A in 5 steps

Company A is fictitious: it rents out and services construction equipment for building contractors. Its strategy has eight criteria of weight 1, two of them on valuation.

StepCompany A
1. The businessEquipment rental with three-year service contracts, 70% of revenue from recurring contracts
2. The accountsRevenue growth of 7% a year over 5 years, operating margin of 16%, ROIC of 13%, net debt / EBITDA of 2.4, FCF conversion of 75%
3. The criteriaSix criteria met, two to monitor (debt above 2, FCF conversion below 80%), score of 88: “Criteria partly met”
4. The priceP/E of 14 against a maximum of 18, FCF yield of 6% against a minimum of 5%
5. The decision“I’m watching”. Main risk: debt, with an invalidation threshold at 3 times EBITDA. Next reread at the half-yearly report

Six green criteria and two orange ones give 14 points out of 16, or 88: two points short of 90. The calculation is detailed in the article on the stock scoring system.

How does ruly support these five steps?

ruly takes over at step 3. You choose a strategy, preset or your own, you enter by hand the figures read in step 2, and each criterion gets its verdict, then the sheet its score out of 100. Steps 1 and 2 stay with you: ruly provides no market data.

For step 4, the sheet header takes your “Fair value”, your own estimate per share. A margin of safety criterion, like the one in the Value preset strategy, compares it with the share price. For step 5, the “Thesis, risks and decision” section keeps your thesis, your risks, a comment shown on the dashboard and your decision. The details are on the Features page.

Frequently asked questions

Can you skip the business step?

Better not. Without it, you do not know which figures matter: an operating margin of 10% is low for a software publisher and high for a food distributor.

Why judge the price after the criteria?

So the share price does not color how you read the figures. A company whose share price just fell quickly looks cheaper, and its weaknesses less serious. Rated on its figures first, it gets the same treatment as the others.

Should you redo the whole analysis every year?

Steps 1 and 5 get reread, steps 2 to 4 get redone with the new figures. The annual report is the right moment: its accounts are audited and its notes are complete.

How do you compare two stocks you have analyzed?

With the same strategy, and by reading the verdict of each criterion rather than the score alone. Two companies with the same score can have opposite profiles: one highly profitable but indebted, the other average everywhere.

Start free

Build your strategy, score each stock against your own criteria and note your decision next to the figures.

Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.

Read next