Skip to content
ruly

Stock scoring system: from criterion verdicts to a score out of 100

A stock scoring system out of 100: points per verdict, the orange zone, weights, criteria left out and overall verdict cutoffs, then the limits of a single score, worked out.

To score a stock, give each criterion a verdict, then points: 2 for a criterion met, 1 for a criterion to monitor, 0 for a criterion not met. Multiply each result by the criterion’s weight, add them up, divide by the total possible and scale to 100. Then read the detail: a single score can hide a deal-breaker criterion.

How do you turn a criterion into points?

Each criterion first gets a verdict, based on the threshold you set. That verdict then becomes points:

VerdictPoints
“Criterion met”2
“To monitor”1
“Criterion not met”0

The threshold is a minimum (ROIC of at least 12%) or a maximum (net debt / EBITDA of 2 at most). A second, looser threshold opens the orange zone. With a minimum of 12% and orange from 8%, a ROIC of 13% scores 2 points, a ROIC of 10% scores 1 point, and a ROIC of 7% scores 0.

Without an orange zone, a ROIC of 11.9% would score 0 and a ROIC of 12% would score 2: a tenth of a point would flip the whole criterion. The middle level softens that cliff and flags the figures worth tracking.

Two other forms are scored the same way. A range, such as a dividend yield between 2.5% and 6%, is green in the middle and orange at the edges. A yes-or-no criterion scores 2 or 0.

How do you calculate the score out of 100?

  1. For each criterion, multiply its points by its weight.
  2. Add up these products: that is the total earned.
  3. Add up the weights and multiply by 2: that is the total possible, the total of a company that would meet every criterion.
  4. Divide the total earned by the total possible, multiply by 100 and round to the nearest whole number.

In one line: score = 100 × sum of (weight × points) / (2 × sum of weights).

With three criteria of weight 1, 2 and 3, rated green, orange and red: 1 × 2 + 2 × 1 + 3 × 0 = 4 points, out of 2 × 6 = 12 possible. The score is 100 × 4 / 12 = 33.

What does a criterion’s weight do?

The weight says how much a criterion counts against the others. A criterion of weight 3 counts as much as three criteria of weight 1. Its share of the score equals its weight divided by the sum of the weights.

Do that calculation before you set a high weight. With eight criteria of weight 1 and a ninth of weight 5, the last one accounts for 5 / 13 of the total, or 38% of the score on its own.

How to choose and weight the criteria is covered in the article on the stock investment checklist.

What do you do with a criterion that does not apply?

Leave it out of the calculation, from the points earned and from the points possible. A criterion that does not apply is not worth 0: it does not exist for that company. The gross margin of a bank or the net debt / EBITDA of an insurer are in that situation.

The difference matters. Company C, a fictitious bank, is scored on six criteria of weight 1. Five are met, and gross margin means nothing for a bank:

  1. Gross margin left out: 10 points out of 10 possible, a score of 100.
  2. Gross margin counted as not met: 10 points out of 12 possible, a score of 83.

Seventeen points of difference come from a criterion that measures nothing there.

Do not confuse “not applicable” with “not filled in”. A figure you have not found yet is still to be found: a score calculated without it no longer covers the same strategy. Criteria written as free text (the target market, a catalyst) are not scored at all: they inform your decision without entering the score.

Which cutoffs for the overall verdict?

A score on its own is hard to read. Three bands turn it into an overall verdict, the ones ruly uses:

ScoreOverall verdictWith 10 criteria of weight 1
90 to 100“Criteria met”One red at most, or two oranges and no red
50 to 89“Criteria partly met”Ten oranges give 50
0 to 49“Criteria not met”More reds than greens

The 90 cutoff therefore tolerates one criterion not met out of ten. A score of 90 does not mean every criterion is met.

Why can a single score mislead you?

The score adds things up: a criterion met by a wide margin offsets a criterion missed. This offsetting effect has two consequences.

  1. A good score can hide a deal-breaker. If net debt / EBITDA above 3 is enough to make you pass on a company, no score should be able to erase it. Always read the verdict of each criterion, and treat such a criterion separately: a rule written before the analysis, applied before you look at the score.
  2. Two scores only compare under the same strategy. A 70 earned under a valuation-focused strategy and a 70 earned under a growth-focused strategy do not measure the same thing. Even with a single strategy, changing a threshold changes every score: compare sheets scored with the same criteria and the same thresholds.

Worked example: Company A and Company B, same score, opposite profiles

Company A and Company B are fictitious. They are scored with the same six-criterion strategy. The weights add up to 10, so the total possible is 20 points.

CriterionRule
Average ROIC over 5 yearsAt least 12%, orange from 8%, weight 3
Operating marginAt least 15%, orange from 10%, weight 1
Revenue growth, 5 yearsAt least 6% a year, orange from 3%, weight 1
Net debt / EBITDA2 at most, orange up to 3, weight 2
FCF conversionAt least 80%, orange from 60%, weight 1
FCF yieldAt least 5%, orange from 3%, weight 2

Their figures, verdicts and points:

CriterionCompany ACompany B
ROIC20%, green, 6 points10%, orange, 3 points
Operating margin26%, green, 2 points12%, orange, 1 point
Revenue growth10%, green, 2 points4%, orange, 1 point
Net debt / EBITDA3.8, red, 0 points0.6, green, 4 points
FCF conversion98%, green, 2 points70%, orange, 1 point
FCF yield2.1%, red, 0 points4%, orange, 2 points
Total12 out of 2012 out of 20

Both get 100 × 12 / 20 = 60: “Criteria partly met”.

The same 60 describes two opposite companies. Company A meets four criteria out of six, including the heaviest one, but its debt is above your maximum and its FCF yield is low. Company B meets only one criterion, misses none, and is average everywhere.

What if debt is your deal-breaker?

Two ways to express it in the strategy:

  1. Raise its weight to 5. The sum of the weights rises to 13, the total possible to 26. Company A keeps 12 points: 100 × 12 / 26 = 46, “Criteria not met”. Company B rises to 18 points, or 69. But a company green everywhere except on debt would still get 16 out of 26, or 62: the weight moves the score without ruling anyone out.
  2. Make it a separate rule. Write before the analysis: “net debt / EBITDA above 3, I pass, whatever the score”. Company A stops at that criterion, and the score only serves to rank the companies that clear the rule.

Either way, what you do with Company A or Company B remains your decision: the score describes the sheets against your criteria.

How does ruly calculate the score?

In ruly, each criterion of your strategy gets a verdict as you type: “Criterion met”, “To monitor” or “Criterion not met”. Each criterion weighs 1 to 5 in the score, a “Not applicable” box takes it out of the calculation, and free-text criteria are “Not scored”.

The score out of 100 follows the formula above. It appears once the sheet is complete, when every scored and applicable criterion is filled in, and it gives the overall verdict: “Criteria met” from 90, “Criteria partly met” from 50 to 89, “Criteria not met” below 50. Your decision (“I’m buying as a priority”, “I’m buying”, “I’m watching”, “I’m waiting for a better price”, “I’m passing” or “Not decided yet”) does not count in the score. The dashboard shows the score of each sheet, one row per stock.

With the paid plan, a frozen version keeps the score with a copy of the strategy as it was that day: changing a threshold later does not change the versions already frozen. The details are on the Features page.

Frequently asked questions

Is a score of 90 enough to invest?

It says that the company meets the criteria you chose, with the figures you entered. It is neither advice nor a forecast, and it can include a criterion not met. Read the verdict of each criterion before you decide.

How do you score a qualitative criterion?

Turn it into a closed question when you can: does the company have a lasting competitive advantage? Yes scores 2, no scores 0. A choice between several answers, each with its own color, works too. Whatever cannot be reduced to an answer stays as text, outside the score.

Why 2, 1 and 0 points rather than 1 and 0?

To give the borderline figure a place. With 1 and 0, a criterion almost met is worth the same as a criterion far from the threshold. The middle point keeps that nuance without changing the order of the verdicts.

My score drops from one year to the next: what should I look at?

The criteria that changed color, before the score itself. With a total possible of 20, a ten-point drop can come from a single criterion of weight 2 going from green to orange, or a criterion of weight 1 going from green to red. Also check that your thresholds did not change between the two sheets.

Start free

Build your strategy, score each stock against your own criteria and note your decision next to the figures.

Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.

Read next