Skip to content
ruly

Review stocks after earnings: a 20-minute routine for each release

Review stocks after earnings in 20 minutes: reread your thesis, read the right documents, strip out one-off items, update your criteria and date your decision. Worked example.

To review your stocks after earnings without losing an evening, run the same 20-minute routine at every release: reread your thesis and thresholds before opening the figures, read the press release and then the full report, strip out one-off items, update each criterion, note the verdicts that change and date your decision.

What routine fits in 20 minutes?

Six steps, always in the same order. The times are a guide: they mostly stop you from spending two hours on commentary that changes nothing.

  1. Reread (3 minutes). Your thesis, your risks with their invalidation threshold, and the last value of each criterion. Write in one line what you expect: “operating margin around 17%”.
  2. Read the press release (4 minutes). Spot the headline figures, the comparison with the same period last year and what management says about the outlook.
  3. Find your figures in the report (6 minutes). Income statement, balance sheet, cash flow statement and notes: that is where the values of your criteria are.
  4. Strip out one-off items (3 minutes). Put a figure on each exceptional item and decide whether you remove it from the calculation.
  5. Update and compare (2 minutes). Enter the new values, recalculate the criteria that use the share price, list the verdicts that change color.
  6. Decide and date (2 minutes). One line of decision, even if unchanged, with the date and the document used.

Step 1 matters more than it looks. If you read the press release first, management chooses the angle of your reading. If you reread your thesis first, you look for your own figures.

To reread a journal entry after earnings and keep a record of these rereads over time, follow the method of the investment decision journal. This article covers reading the results themselves.

Which documents should you read, and in what order?

Three documents usually come with a release. They do not say the same thing.

DocumentWhat you look for
Earnings press releaseThe figures the company puts forward, and its outlook
Investor presentationThe split by business or region, and the metrics management tracks
Full half-yearly or annual reportThe accounts, the notes and the cash flows, where your criteria come from

The company writes the press release, so it chooses what goes at the top. When it puts forward an “adjusted” or “underlying” result, look in the report for the reconciliation from the reported figure to the adjusted one, and check what was taken out.

Take the values of your criteria from the report, never from the press release alone. Free cash flow, for example, is calculated from the cash flow statement, which the press release often sums up in one line.

Which figures are published, and how often?

It depends on where the company is listed. The pace sets how many reviews you do each year.

ReleaseEuropean UnionUnited States
Annual reportRequired, within 4 months of year-end10-K
Half-yearly reportRequired, within 3 months of the half-year endNo dedicated report
Quarterly informationOptional10-Q, for each of the first three quarters

In the European Union, the Transparency Directive requires the annual report and the half-yearly report. Since its 2013 revision, quarterly information is no longer mandatory for companies listed on a regulated market. In France, the market regulator (AMF) confirmed in 2015 that each company chooses whether to publish it. Some still do, often with revenue only.

In the United States, a company files a 10-Q after each of the first three fiscal quarters and none for the fourth: the full year goes through the 10-K. The filing deadlines are covered in the article on the investment decision journal.

Two practical consequences:

  • A quarterly release limited to revenue only updates your growth criteria. Leave the others alone.
  • Compare a half-year with the same half-year of the previous year, not with the half before: many businesses are seasonal. For an annual criterion such as ROIC, use the trailing twelve months (TTM).

How do you spot one-off items?

A one-off item inflates or crushes a result without saying anything about the ongoing business. The most common ones:

  1. A gain on disposal of a subsidiary or a building.
  2. An impairment of assets or goodwill.
  3. Restructuring costs: layoffs, a plant closure.
  4. Litigation: a fine, a provision, a settlement received.
  5. A scope or currency effect on growth: an acquisition adds revenue without any growth in the existing business. Organic growth excludes it.

You find them in the notes and in management’s discussion, rarely in the headline of the press release. Remove an item only if the report lets you put a figure on it, and write down what you removed.

A common rule of thumb: an “exceptional” item that comes back in three fiscal years out of five is part of the business. A company that restructures every year has recurring restructuring costs.

Worked example: Company A at the half-yearly report

Company A is fictitious. It makes industrial measuring instruments. Your strategy has five criteria of equal weight, and your previous decision was “I’m watching”: the P/E was above your maximum.

Criterion (green / orange)First half, year 1First half, year 2
Organic growth (5% / 2%)7%, green3%, orange
Operating margin (15% / 10%)17%, green15% adjusted, green
ROIC, trailing 12 months (12% / 8%)14%, green13%, green
Net debt / EBITDA (1.5 / 2.5 at most)0.8, green2.2, orange
P/E (20 / 25 at most)22, orange18, green

What the routine brings out:

  1. The press release announces 9% growth. The report shows that an acquisition contributes 6 points: organic growth is 3%.
  2. The reported margin is 12%, with 3 points of restructuring costs tied to the acquisition. You keep it at 15%, and you write that down. Without this adjustment, the criterion would turn orange.
  3. The acquisition was partly paid with debt: net debt / EBITDA goes from 0.8 to 2.2. Your invalidation threshold, written in the risks, was 2.5. It is not crossed.
  4. The share price fell: the P/E goes from 22 to 18.

The score goes from 90 to 80. Three verdicts change color, and only one improves: the P/E, which follows the share price. The other two point to a slowing business and a heavier balance sheet.

The decision stays “I’m watching”. You note the date, the year 2 half-yearly report, and two conditions to check at the annual report: organic growth back at 5%, net debt / EBITDA back below 1.5. If either moves further away, your exit criteria, written in advance, take over.

How does ruly help you review a sheet after earnings?

In ruly, you enter the new figures on the existing sheet. Each value gets a verdict against the thresholds of your strategy: “Criterion met”, “To monitor” or “Criterion not met”. The score is recalculated over the criteria that are scored and applicable, and a criterion marked “Not applicable” drops out of the score. Your thesis, your risks, your comment and your decision stay on the same sheet.

With the paid plan, freeze a version after each release. Frozen versions keep the score, the verdict and the value of each criterion on that date, with a copy of the strategy as it was. The table of versions shows what changed from one release to the next, and the score curve appears from three versions. The thesis and the risks are not frozen: date each update in their text yourself.

Frequently asked questions

Should I review every stock every quarter?

Review each stock at each release that contains the figures of your criteria. For a European company that only publishes quarterly revenue, the full routine runs twice a year, at the half-year and at year-end. The rest of the time, a glance at your growth criteria is enough.

The share price moves sharply on earnings day: should I take it into account?

Only for the criteria that use the share price, such as the P/E. Recalculate them at the price of the day you do your review, and note that price. A price move changes what you would pay, and none of the company’s figures.

What if I don’t have time to read the full report?

Do steps 1, 2 and 6, and note that the review is partial. Go back to the report within the week. A decision based on the press release alone rests on the figures the company chose.

Should I react when the company lowers its guidance?

Write it in your risks, with the figure that would confirm it in the next report. Guidance is a forecast by management. Your criteria rest on published figures, and the next release will show whether the forecast was right.

Start free

Build your strategy, score each stock against your own criteria and note your decision next to the figures.

Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.

Read next

Sources