Individual stocks vs ETFs: when picking your own stocks makes sense
Individual stocks vs ETFs: time, diversification, fees and behavior compared, the conditions under which picking your own stocks makes sense, and a mixed approach with figures.
An index ETF gives you a whole market in one line, for little time and modest fees. Picking individual stocks takes hours of analysis, a written method and acceptance of a result that will differ from the index, in either direction. Many investors combine the two: an index core and a smaller pocket of stocks they choose themselves.
What is the difference between stock picking and ETFs?
Stock picking means choosing each company you invest in yourself. An ETF is an exchange-traded fund that tracks an index: in one line, you own all the companies in it, in their index weights.
Both approaches draw more and more individual investors. In France, according to the AMF, the market regulator, more than 1.1 million people made at least one ETF transaction in 2025, up from 607,000 in 2024, and just over 1.9 million traded shares. The count now also includes clients of providers based elsewhere in the European Union, so compare 2025 with 2024 with care.
How do individual stocks and ETFs compare?
| Criterion | ETF | Stocks you pick |
|---|---|---|
| Time | A few minutes per contribution | Hours per company, then a reread at each release |
| Diversification | Dozens to thousands of companies in one line | Whatever you build, line by line |
| Fees | The fund’s annual expense ratio, plus commissions | Commissions on each order, no management fee |
| Behavior | Few decisions, so few chances to get it wrong | Each line is a decision that emotion can bend |
| Result | The index’s, minus fees | Different from the index, above or below |
| Interest | No analysis work | Understanding businesses, which motivates some investors |
No row of this table names a winner. Each one describes what the approach asks of you, and what it gives back.
What are the risks of stock picking?
The first risk is concentration. With ten companies, one analysis mistake weighs a tenth of your pocket. In a fund of several hundred companies, it goes almost unnoticed.
The second is behavior. Following stocks one by one multiplies the chances to act on a price move or a headline, and those heat-of-the-moment decisions have a cost. The article on how to stick to your investment rules covers this trap and how to guard against it.
The third is time. A pocket of chosen stocks can do worse than the index for several years in a row, even with a sound method. No one can promise you otherwise.
When does picking your own stocks make sense?
Stock picking makes sense when these five conditions are all met. If one is missing, an index fund answers your need more simply, at least until you meet it.
- You have time, regularly. Count one full analysis per new company, then two rereads a year per line. With ten lines and one hour per reread, that is already twenty hours a year, before any new analysis.
- Your method is written before the first order. Criteria, thresholds, number of lines, maximum weight per line. A stock investment checklist is its simplest form.
- You accept a result that differs from the index. Several years of gap, in either direction, without changing method after each disappointment.
- You know why you are doing it. Understanding businesses, applying your own criteria, learning. If your only reason is to get more than the index, nothing ensures you will.
- A mistake does not threaten your plans. The pocket of chosen stocks must be able to lose part of its value without touching the money you need.
| Your situation | The most consistent approach |
|---|---|
| Less than an hour a month to spare | Index funds only |
| Time, but no written method yet | Index funds, while you write your method |
| Time, a written method, a wish to analyze | Mixed approach |
How do you combine ETFs and individual stocks?
The mixed approach puts most of your savings in one or more index funds, the core, and a smaller share in chosen stocks, the pocket. Four rules, written in advance, make it workable.
- Set the size of the pocket. For example 30% of the total at most. Choose it by asking yourself what gap with the index you could live with for several years.
- Set a maximum weight per stock. For example 12% of the total, so that a single mistake stays bearable.
- Decide when to rebalance. Once a year, or when a limit is crossed. New contributions can often correct a gap without parting with anything.
- Look for overlaps. The companies you choose are often already in your fund’s index. Adding them directly raises your exposure to them.
Worked example: Company A, B and C next to an index fund
Company A, Company B and Company C are fictitious, as are all the weights and price moves below, given for illustration. The written rules are those of the previous section: a pocket of 30% at most, 12% at most per stock.
| Line | At the start | One year later |
|---|---|---|
| Index fund | $14,000 (70%) | $14,840 (+6%) |
| Company A | $2,400 (12%) | $2,880 (+20%) |
| Company B | $1,800 (9%) | $1,530 (−15%) |
| Company C | $1,800 (9%) | $1,836 (+2%) |
| Total | $20,000 | $21,086 |
Reading one year later:
- The pocket is worth $6,246, or +4.1%, against +6% for the fund. Its result differs from the index, this year on the downside.
- The pocket makes up 29.6% of the total, below the 30% maximum: nothing to do.
- Company A makes up 13.7% of the total, above the 12% maximum. The planned rule applies: trim A, or direct the next contributions to the rest.
- Company B fell 15%. The price alone triggers nothing: reread its criteria and your thesis at the next earnings release, and decide on the figures.
How does ruly track your pocket of chosen stocks?
ruly is for analyzing stocks one by one. Each company in your pocket has its sheet: your figures entered by hand, a verdict for each criterion of your strategy, a score, your thesis, your risks and your decision.
The dashboard shows the whole pocket, one row per company, with the score, the decision and your comment. With the paid plan, frozen versions keep a dated snapshot of each sheet: at each reread, you see which criteria changed since the last one.
Frequently asked questions
Does picking stocks earn more than an ETF?
No one can promise that. A pocket of chosen stocks gets a result that differs from the index, sometimes above, sometimes below, and sometimes for several years in a row. A written method makes your decisions consistent with each other, without setting any result.
What share of my portfolio should go to individual stocks?
No share suits everyone. Set it in writing by asking yourself what gap with the index you would accept for several years without changing method. Starting small leaves time to test your method.
How many stocks make a diversified pocket?
The number matters less than their variety. Ten companies in the same industry are less diversified than six companies from different industries and countries. Set a maximum weight per stock and per industry, and a number of lines you can reread seriously.
Can I move gradually from ETFs to stock picking?
Yes. First analyze a few companies and record your decisions without investing, then reread them after the next earnings releases. If the method works and time allows, open a small pocket, within limits written in advance.
Build your strategy, score each stock against your own criteria and note your decision next to the figures.
Free for up to 3 sheets, with no time limit. An email address is all you need, and your sheets stay private.